Best Toilet Flappers to Save You Water with every Flush

Ian Mutuli
Updated on
Ian Mutuli

Ian Mutuli

Founder and Managing Editor of Archute. He is also a graduate architect from The University of Nairobi, Kenya.
Get Smarter On Architecture and Design

Get the 3-minute weekly newsletter keeping 5K+ designers in the loop.

Enter your Email to Sign up

Side-bar-footer-forum

An improperly flushing toilet can make you crazy and spoil your day. Toilets are mechanical devices that require well-functioning parts. Flappers are essential for getting the proper flush. The best toilet flappers enable water to pass through with the ideal pressure, creating a fresh and clean bathroom.

Best Toilet Flappers

1. Korky Toilet Repair

Sale
Korky 100BP Ultra High Performance Flapper Fits Most...
  • UNIVERSAL FLAPPER: The 2" universal flapper adjusts to fit flush...
  • FOR LEAKING & RUNNING TOILETS: Save on expensive water waste with...
  • LONG LASTING CHLORAZONE red rubber resists chlorine, bacteria,...
  • WHY KORKY: Our high quality toilet products are universal &...
  • REPLACEMENT TOILET PARTS: Try Korky Toilet Repair because we...

The most versatile flapper on the market is the Korky toilet flapper. The set works with toilet models that are between 1.2 and 5 flushes per gallon, and it is perfect for 2-inch toilets. With the proper pressure, the flapper guarantees a smooth toilet flush.

Korky has a durable rubber that won't wear away after years of exposure to chlorine. The flapper won't be impacted by other kinds of water, such as treated, hard, or well water.

Korky toilet flapper has a tight seal that saves you a lot of money by preventing leakages. The Korky flapper can fit almost any flush valve drain. The toilet tank flapper is adjustable and a stainless steel chain that is kink and rust-resistant. With different settings to fit the popular sizes in the market, the flapper is versatile yet still more functional than its counterparts.

The toilet flapper matches settings to either reduce or increase the amount of water that gets flushed to its appropriate level.

Pros:

  • The flapper sends high-pressure water into the toilet bowl.
  • Easy to install.
  • The toilet flapper is versatile and can be adjusted to fit flush valves of different sizes.
  • Korky works in toilets with between 1.2 and 5 gallons-per-flush ratings.
  • Korky is a universal toilet flapper for the different models in the market.
  • Best toilet flapper to prevent leaks and save money in the long run.
  • Korky is a rubber flapper that creates a watertight seal.
  • The toilet flapper is made of high-quality rubber that will resist chlorine in any amount.
  • The toilet flappers can work with hard water, city water treatment, well water, and any hard water.
  • The flapper has a stainless steel chain that is rust and kink-resistant.
  • Perfect fill-valve fit.
  • Long-lasting.

Cons:

  • The flappers will still lead to a leaking toilet if not fitted correctly.

2. TOTO Flapper Replacement

The quantity of water wasted every day when your toilet has an outdated flapper is substantial. The best solution for a malfunctioning toilet system is the TOTO toilet flapper. The toilet flapper is composed of a sturdy, lightweight plastic body. Furthermore, the flapper's polypropylene body is strong and impervious to deterioration from many chemicals and water kinds.

The rubber sealing on the toilet flapper does a fantastic job of maintaining the water in the tank at all times. To prevent any extra water from leaking out of the toilet's tank, the flapper covers three inches of the valve seat.

The flapper is easy to install and has instructional videos online. You do not have to call a plumber to fix the toilet anymore.

Pros:

  • TOTO is made up of polyethylene which is a corrosion-resistant material.
  • Water-saving features including the rubber sealing that keeps the water in the tank.
  • The 3-inch flapper has a high tolerance for chlorine, hard water, well water, and any chemicals in the water.
  • The flapper opens and closes smoothly for a high-pressure flush.
  • The flapper is durable and will serve you for a long time.

Cons:

  • The flapper covers only 3-inch flush valves.

3. Kohler Genuine Part Toilet Flapper

Kohler (BLUE PART GP85160 FLAPPER WITH FLOAT), 2
  • Protect the warranty on KOHLER products, always look for the...
  • 2 in. flapper with a float used in various 1.6 GPF two piece...
  • Also used in KALLISTA toilets
  • Compatible with the following KOHLER Models: Wellworth 3114,...
  • Devonshire 3457, Revival 3555, Memoirs 3452, 3462, Crimson Topaz...

The market's best and most efficient toilet flappers are made by Kohler. Long-term water savings are achieved by the system's seamless flush cycle, which integrates with the overflow tube. To stop any leaks at all, the flapper also tightly closes the valve drain opening.

For two-piece toilets, a float is fastened to a stainless steel chain by the toilet flapper. Enough water is kept in the tank to hold the proper quantity of potential energy thanks to the toilet flapper valve's tight fit.

The toilet flapper valves fit most toilets that have a 1.6 gallons-per-flush.

The parts of the toilet flapper are made of durable materials that can withstand corrosion from any water. In addition, the toilet flapper has a kink-free chain that attaches to the floater. The chain is rust-free and lasts longer than other flappers.

The flapper firmly attaches to the overflow pipe for maximum water saving during toilet flushing. The flapper has a solid frame that can go for endless flush cycles without breaking down. In addition, the seamless functioning of the flapper valve ensures enough pressure for the toilet paper to get flushed away completely.

Pros:

  • The flapper drops seamlessly in place after every flush.
  • Water-saving flapper.
  • Watertight seal to prevent ghost flushing.
  • Fits 2-inch flush toilets.
  • Kohler has a float that can work for two-piece toilets.
  • Best toilet flapper for longevity.

Cons:

  • The flapper is not universal and fits specifically to some toilet models.

4. Fluidmaster Universal Toilet Flapper

Sale
Fluidmaster 502P21 PerforMAX Universal Water-Saving...
  • LONG-LASTING DURABILITY: Toilet flapper with solid frame replaces...
  • UNIVERSAL DESIGN: Adjustable flapper fits most 2-inch flush valve...
  • ADJUSTABLE TO SAVE WATER: Dial flapper adjusts for maximum flush...
  • CORROSION RESISTANT: Solid frame 502 2-inch flapper features...
  • EASY INSTALLATION: Easily installs in 10 minutes or less to...

The best addition to your toilet tank is the Fluidmaster flapper. For optimal effectiveness, the toilet flapper fits 2-inch flush valves precisely. Furthermore, the flapper features a sturdy frame design that can be adjusted and is adaptable to various toilet tanks.

The Fluidmaster toilet flapper fits the valve precisely and is simple to install, allowing for smooth opening and closing. Furthermore, the flapper is nicely designed to fill the flush valve seat without creating any leaky gaps.

The toilet flapper has a strong structure that prevents twisting during the opening and closing of the flapper valve. In addition, the flexible and solid frame prevents ghost flushing, corroded flappers, and running toilet problems.

The flapper is adjustable to save water wastage through the leakage. In addition, the flapper adjustment further increases the flush efficiency.

Fluidmaster is made up of Microban material that prevents breakdown that leads to leakage. The material is chlorine resistant and keeps the bacteria away. Hard water does not affect the toilet flapper either. Fluidmaster is the best replacement flapper for the old ones that are leaking in the toilet.

Pros:

  • Easy installation
  • Adjustable toilet flapper
  • Durable toilet flapper
  • Prevents ghost flushing
  • The flapper is made of material that prevents corroding from chemicals.
  • Chlorine resistant
  • Flapper works seamlessly with the toilet fill valve.
  • Universal flapper.
  • Best toilet flapper for increased flush efficiency.

Cons:

  • The flapper only fits 2-inch flush valves.

5. Uming Toilet Flapper Replacement

Toilet Flapper Replacement 2 inch (2 Pack) Universal...
  • Get the Solution for hissing and leaking toilets - Fixes leaky...
  • Easy to Install in Seconds - No tools required. Loosen the clips...
  • 2'' Meets Most American Standard Toilet - This universal toilet...
  • Long Lasting Flapper & Stainless Chain - Built with soft durable...
  • Water Saving, Cost Saving - With the toilet flapper, you can...

A leak is most likely the cause of the odd hissing sound coming from the toilet. The toilet tank continually refills to restore the lost water due to a leak in the flush valve drain opening. The ideal alternative to outdated toilet flappers is rubber ones.

Installing Uming toilet flappers is simple and doesn't require any tools. The toilet flappers are attached to the fill valve by a chain and are held in position by clips. Because of this, installing the flapper just takes a few seconds.

Uming is compatible with other toilet brands and most of America's standard toilets. The flapper is long-lasting and is built using rubber. Toilet flappers made of rubber are resistant to chlorine, hard water, well water, other chemicals, and bacteria. In addition, the flappers are long-lasting and do not wear off easily.

The toilet flappers will save you water and the cost of constantly repairing the toilet. Uming fixes the double toilet flush, a running toilet, and a worn and leaky toilet flapper. In addition, the toilet tank will stay full after every flush when you install Uming.

Pros:

  • The flapper saves cost and water.
  • Easy installation.
  • The toilet flapper adjusts to fit different toilets.
  • Chemical resistant.
  • Long-lasting.
  • Chlorine resistant.
  • Best toilet flappers that are compatible with most standard toilets in America.
  • Prevents double toilet flushes.

Cons:

  • Fits only a 2-inch flush valve tank

Factors to Consider Before Buying Toilet Flappers

a) Size

The majority of flappers use the standard 2-inch size. However, there are some toilets with different flush valve sizes that need their flappers. In addition, some flappers are size-specific and need to be matched correctly with the toilet.

The size of the flapper will determine how well it will sit in the tank. If the tank ball is not compatible with the tank, there will be endless leakage. There are flappers meant for two-piece toilets. The sizes will slightly vary. The flapper needs to be the exact size for the toilet to work seamlessly.

b) Material

Since the flapper will primarily be submerged in the water, the material used to construct it is quite important. Chlorine is one among many chemicals used to treat water that eventually corrode. Nonetheless, the substance needs to have a long-term resistance to water.

The flapper will eventually suffer from hard water, well water, or any other type of water. As a result, rubber flappers survive longer than flappers manufactured of any other material. Rubber resists deterioration over time and is resistant to chlorine. Consequently, any germs present in the water will not have an impact on the flapper.

The material used to make the flapper is either flexible or not. The flexible material can fit easily into holes and has a surface that can remain watertight for a long period. The chain needs to be made with stainless steel that does not rust easily.

c) Compatibility

Toilet flappers are parts of a toilet that work with other parts. The better the flappers fit during a toilet flapper replacement, the more seamless the whole system will work. A loose replacement toilet flapper leads to leaking of the whole system. Leaking leads to the wastage of water and money.

Flappers can either be 2, 3 inches, or larger. A small or oversized flapper will not open and close seamlessly, leading to less pressure on the water entering the toilet bowl. A leaky flapper is a flapper that probably did not fit well in the tank. The tank ball needs to sit well in the toilet for the efficient functioning of the whole system.

d) Easy Installation

Calling a plumber and paying them to fix a damaged flapper is not sufficient. Flappers are inexpensive because they are easy to install and use. For anyone who is unsure of what they are doing, a basic YouTube tutorial will be helpful.

A decent flapper can be installed without the need of any tools. A toilet tank flapper, for instance, contains clips to retain the flapper in place after installation for increased durability and efficiency.

e) Water Type

The flapper's lifespan is influenced by the kind of water entering the tank. The materials that water comes into contact with are greatly impacted. The best response is certainly ceramic, but ceramic cannot be used to make a flapper. Unless the tank is drained, a flapper remains submerged in the water at all times and remains drenched.

Plastic and polyethylene function well since water does not readily erode them. Rubber is superior for compatibility, though.

Well, water contains different chemicals from the ground. The water might be salty and filled with different compounds that seep into the well from the ground. The water can harbor different kinds of bacteria that lead to the reduction of the flapper life.

For anyone living near the coast, the water will take a toll on the metal chains on the flapper. Steel tends to rust faster when exposed to ocean water compared to other kinds of water. The water needs to undergo a lot of treatment to prevent the formation of scum and other forms of residue. Hard water affects the flapper.

f) Warranty

Having a warranty guarantees that you will receive the best products available. It can be challenging to determine which of the numerous products is ideal for your needs. If the product does not work with your system, you have the option to return it under warranty. When making a purchase, read product reviews.

Ian Mutuli

About the author

Ian Mutuli

Founder and Managing Editor of Archute. He is also a graduate architect from The University of Nairobi, Kenya.
Related Articles
bathroom cabinet colors

20 Best Bathroom Cabinet Colors for an Elegant Look

Bathrooms are some of the most functional areas of the home, but that does not mean that they should look ...

Best Color for Bathroom Interior and How to Match Them

Choosing the best color for your bathroom interior can transform it from a simple functional space into a relaxing sanctuary. ...

14 Do’s And Don’ts Of Bathroom Remodeling To Consider

People often expect to experience stress and mess when they consider renovating their homes. The truth is that there’s a ...